CarGurus expert rating: 4 out of 5
CarGurus user rating: 5.0 out of 5
Percentage of good/great deals available on CarGurus: 33.3%
Overall CarGurus rating:* 4.3 out of 5
Available Listings: Around 50
Average Price: N/A

Tesla Model S (2014-present) Pros and Cons

Pros	Cons
Mind-bending acceleration	The interior could be better finished
Excellent range and charging network	Some question marks over reliability
Very well equipped	More recent Tesla models are cheaper to buy new

Quick Summary

The Tesla Model S is a groundbreaking all-electric saloon that combines comfort, refinement, serious performance and advanced technology. Even in basic rear-wheel-drive form, it accelerates from 0-60mph in 5.9 seconds, whilst the range-topping Performance Plus variant achieves this in just 4.2 seconds. The entry-level 60kWh model offers a claimed 240 miles of range, with the 85kWh variant extending this to 310 miles—figures that far exceed early competitors like the Nissan Leaf. Its minimalist interior is spacious for four adults, with an enormous 709-litre boot and an 89-litre frunk, expanding to 1,739 litres with rear seats folded. The large high-definition touchscreen infotainment system and pared-back design make it a standout vehicle.

Running costs are exceptionally low compared to petrol and diesel alternatives, with no fuel expenses, zero VED charges, minimal servicing requirements and low Benefit-in-Kind tax rates. Tesla quotes that charging for 1,000 miles costs £72, versus £284 for a comparable high-performance petrol car. The increasingly widespread Supercharger network makes long-distance travel viable, whilst over-the-air updates continually improve capabilities. However, the interior finish could be better, reliability questions persist, and newer Tesla models offer better value when purchased new. Despite these considerations, the Model S remains an excellent choice for those seeking an electric car with comfort, range and performance.

Best for: Drivers seeking an electric car with serious performance, excellent range and advanced technology; those who travel long distances and want access to a reliable charging network; buyers prioritising low running costs.

Not ideal for: Those seeking a plusher interior finish; buyers concerned about reliability and support; those looking for the most engaging driving experience in the premium electric segment.


Comparison vs Key Rivals



The Verdict

You should buy the Model S if: You're seeking an electric car with serious performance, excellent range and advanced technology; you travel long distances and want access to a reliable charging network; you prioritise low running costs.

Consider alternatives if: You desire a plusher interior finish, are concerned about reliability and support, or seek the most engaging driving experience in the premium electric segment.

Competitive Position: The Tesla Model S is a remarkable machine that effectively demonstrated what an electric car could achieve. Whilst rivals such as the Porsche Taycan offer a more engaging driving experience and potentially better reliability, and the Jaguar I-Pace provides comparable user satisfaction, the Model S's longer claimed range, extensive Supercharger network and comparatively accessible pricing make it a compelling choice. The Audi E-Tron, meanwhile, lags behind in expert ratings. For those prioritising performance, range and value in the premium electric saloon segment, the Model S remains a highly competitive option.

Read our full Tesla Model S Review

*The Overall CarGurus rating: that informs these recommendations is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from May 2026, CarGurus expert reviews, and CarGurus user reviews.

Read full review